Sunday, October 10, 2010

William Faulkner, Turnabout

If I’m to conclude my examination of the relationship between entertainment and meaning, and levels of artistic value, I think it’s pertinent of me to examine William Faulkner’s short story Turnabout. I’ve avoided too much of an investigation of the screenplay because I feel at the moment that my musings are best confined to the medium of prose narrative so I’m going to look at the short story on its own.
I admit to being somewhat sceptical of Modernist prose in spite of being very fond of the corresponding poetry, so I went into reading Turnabout with reservations. Therefore I was glad to find that the story greatly exceeded my expectations. While perhaps a little slow to begin with, I found that the tale did become quite pacey and exciting as it gathered momentum and that it certainly made a rather striking and distinctly Modernist statement about how meaningless the lives of “little people” are made through the machinations of powerful individuals as was so vividly understood in the aftermath of the First World War.
Perhaps this story, then, has been placed as the last major piece of fiction in this course either by providence or sheer coincidence to act as the coalescent manifestation of what I have been trying to argue over the last several blogs. Firstly we have What Maisie Knew, where in my opinion the satirical meaning was very clear, that criticism of Victorian aristocracy, but where the narrative suffered in terms of its engagement with my passion and imagination (not that it was under any obligation to do so; this is a subjective response of course). Then we have The Secret History, where I was inadvertently made a culprit and co-conspirator in murder with a group of individuals of dubious worth, where a thrilling ride inflamed my emotions but where it took me some time and thought to realise where this strong emotional and imaginative excitement was coming from and to discern, then, what this was supposed to mean. So at last we have Turnabout. I am led on a death-defying military escapade with a group of astoundingly bold individuals, and left full of consternation at the uncaring, dehumanising nature of Authority in a general sense, and I feel a satisfying fusion of entertainment and meaning. I feel as if I am contemplating a very ‘whole’ piece of art.
That is not to say by any means that Turnabout was perfect. Perhaps the meaning was made a little too blunt at the end, a little too obvious. The extremely detailed description of Bogard at the beginning seems somewhat amateurish and a confusingly-phrased line towards the conclusion left me unsure, as had just been reported, that Bogard was still alive. In addition I would definitely say that of the three pieces of fiction I’ve discussed, The Secret History was my favourite because I felt like it engaged with me on the most personal level. I’m sure, also, that some people preferred What Maisie Knew. I think the point is that we should not view criticism as a completely objective process, and we should understand it as being linked to our aesthetic appreciation of a text – how much we enjoy it emotionally and imaginatively. Our enjoyment enhances the meaning, and the meaning enhances our enjoyment; I know I for one prefer and find much more engrossing literature which has something to say than any kind of fiction of the pulp variety. That is not to say, either, that the meaning has to be deliberate rather than latent on the part of the author. Regardless, we should strive to appreciate both together. We should avoid viewing criticism as an unaffected, objective exercise when our appreciation is so tied to our subjective enjoyment as well, and by the same token we should avoid viewing enjoyment as frivolous and unimportant compared to making a critique. They are part of the same process and I believe the composition, appreciation and criticism of art would all benefit from understanding the totality of engagement with a text.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Donna Tartt, The Secret History

In my previous entry I declared that I would further expound my ideas for why we should see critical reading as a subjective act tied to one’s personal experience of a text, and therefore consider that a link inevitably exists between criticism and aesthetics, entertainment value or however one seeks to describe the ‘readability’ or enjoyment factor of literature. This is why I think it’s fitting now that I examine Donna Tartt’s The Secret History.
I found something enthralling about this novel. My problem is that I’m not entirely sure what it was. For instance I found the narrator Richard Papen and his Classicist peers to be rather unlikable characters, and the idea of trying to recreate a Bacchanalian orgy seemed too pointlessly atavistic to be a plausible plot device. But I know the kind of passion some Classicists have for their subjects so I could excuse this more or less. What I think sold this novel to me was the gripping tension I found as a result of the murder of Bunny and the main characters’ attempts to evade the law. It reminded me satisfyingly of The Talented Mr Ripley and as much as I disliked these characters I found myself unavoidably empathising with them and wishing for them to succeed.
This is where the crux of the dilemma lies, I feel. I certainly found The Secret History to be entertaining. At times I could scarcely put it down. So was this then purely a piece of entertainment, or was it art? Was I learning something, was I experiencing something valuable, was something being expressed to me by the author, or was I merely being manipulated by clever language and an intriguing plot into letting my emotions and fancies run wild? At its heart I think The Secret History has something incredibly valuable to say, and it’s best summarised by the reply Henry makes to Richard in Richard’s dream. Richard asks his dead friend “Are you happy here?” and Henry replies “Not particularly, but you’re not very happy where you are either.” The freedom of adulthood and the choices available can have serious consequences, the most tragic of which is not death or justice but to end up living out one’s days lonely, unloved, empty and unsatisfied. While we may be gripped by this story, while its events may stoke a fire in our imagination, this message it presents is equally important.
I’m willing to argue that the narrative, the ‘readability’ of The Secret History, compliments its message. The excitement of the middle sections and the terrible open-endedness of its conclusion reflect the experiences of early adulthood in question, while its deftness with making the reader empathise with the criminal actions of its protagonists make the message both universally relevant and deeply personal to the individual psyche. While I think its point may be a little more esoteric than that of What Maisie Knew, for instance, I believe that the point is made well enough. Here, I think, is an example of literature where the emotions inspired by the text are so tied to its meaning that no critique can possibly be an entirely objective or unaffected experience. It is part of the engagement with the novel, and, in my opinion, this really ought to be the case with any such literature. Without engaging the reader on an emotional or imaginative level, the message may as well not exist at all. I suppose, however, that that is the very point of art in general.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Henry James, What Maisie Knew

So as I strive to head off the deadline for blog posts I have opted to take a rather retroactive, course-wise, examination of Henry James’ What Maisie Knew, and what else can be said of it with the benefit of hindsight. In many ways I feel that much of what we have discussed over the course of the semester has involved comparing the perceptions and responses of readers in the simplest sense to that of critics, the purpose and experience of reading as opposed to that of criticism. I strove, as I try to with the majority of literary works, to read and critique What Maisie Knew simultaneously.
What did the novel present to me as a reader? I must confess that the novel did not grip me. I did not find it to be a page-turner. But the critical side of me argues that that is hardly the point. It may be difficult for me to accept, aesthete as I am, but it is very possible for a pacey narrative and strong emotional involvement to distract from the more serious intellectual concerns of a piece of art. This is Victorian literature, after all, with the novel in a relatively early stage of coalescence, and to make a comparison of my limited reading of such fiction, I daresay that Great Expectations, however unbearably tedious I may have found it during my quickly-defeated effort to read the great work, probably has a good deal more to say than a contemporary work such as my beloved Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.
In that sense I think What Maisie Knew has an immense amount to say. One need only glance at the absurdly evasive and euphemistic dialogue of the inarguably foppish Sir Claude to see James’ harsh examination of an upper crust devoid of responsibility and conscience. To pick an example more or less at random, “Her situation, by what has happened, is completely changed; and it’s no use your trying to prove to me that I needn’t take any account of that.” This is Sir Claude in regards to Mrs Beale. Personally at times I could make nothing of what the more heated conversations between the main characters involved due to this incredibly vague use of language, a language where pronouns are used as often as possible to avoid saying names out loud and where complicated romantic and social liaisons are referenced solely by terms like “situation”. It is a world where children are used in affairs too adult for their involvement, and where the process of growing up involves developing into one of these irresponsible, childish creatures such as the four “parents” of the story, selfish and decadent, engaging endlessly in pointless adolescent-like shenanigans.
Maisie’s departure with Mrs. Wix from her two step-parents at the conclusion of the novel expresses a fitting resolution: that only those who are involved with this upper hierarchy but do not come from it can provide some sort of common sense and hope. That in itself opens up the opportunity for many more readings. What this suggests to me, therefore, that as much as it may strive to be separated and objective, criticism is tied and connected to any other form of reading, and that a critique is ultimately just as subjective as any form of entertainment value. I hope to be able to further develop this concept in my ongoing posts.

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Geoffrey O'Brien: Excerpts from The Browser's Ecstasy: A Meditation on Reading


            O’Brien presents a very extravagant, poetic examination of the experience of reading and writing. In these extracts, his initial approach is to muse upon beginnings – not of books, but rather of the experience of reading for people, by describing a child’s impression of reading as a sense of awe and immensity coupled with familiarity, all brought about by the young reader’s slow reading speed and limited experience of the world, where “phrases are enormous chunks of sculpture, weightlessly penetrating space”. O’Brien follows this by suggesting that what is more desirable is reduction and encapsulation: “a box with the world in it: that’s what’s wanted.” Yet while it is true that “it’s a victory over time to shrink all the hours that would have spent reading them into these minutes”, he also claims of the author or ‘storyteller’ that “I have cheated him.” It is dubious that somehow ‘cheating’ the author is really the point of reading prose. Brevity certainly does not constitute superiority, and the more reducible a text, the more at risk it is of having its richness and substance lost.
            It is then however that O’Brien reconciles this notion with the idea of writing as an equally important and fulfilling component of the literary process, with reading as an equivalent and mutual process of invention. The question “In what space does he exist, if not inside her head, a head that exists nowhere but in his deciphering of her words?” conveys this notion of their being a relationship between writer and reader where the two essentially create each other through the correlating processes of authorship and the imagination of the reader filling the spaces and the forms put in place by the author. It is hopeful, then, that this process does not leave the reader and writer with the same sense of horror experienced by the Lovecraft character mentioned in the quote from The Shadow Out of Time.
            From this is the concept expressed in the eponymous section titled “The Browser’s Ecstasy”, in which it is essentially suggested that by being part of the shared concept of literature, all such written works are in some intrinsic fashion related and metafictional: “It’s almost as if the books read each other, the way characters in novels read novels.” Literature, especially fiction, shares these common elements of narrative and causality which unite them into a plausible whole regardless of how unrelated “Inspector French” may be from “a world consisting of nothing but Canada” or “the paranoid century, the reader’s own.” O’Brien compares this in the final section to the perceived obligations of what he terms “true reading”, that to examine a work in its totality is quite a different kind of world-containment than is perceived by viewing the whole continuity of fiction in one great browse of snippets, but surely this is the fulfilment of the ecstasy of the browser: that it permits a choice for specificity and focus, the deeper freedom to “tear open the box of stories looking for what was still hidden in it, the one I haven’t heard.”