O’Brien presents a very extravagant, poetic examination of the experience of reading and writing. In these extracts, his initial approach is to muse upon beginnings – not of books, but rather of the experience of reading for people, by describing a child’s impression of reading as a sense of awe and immensity coupled with familiarity, all brought about by the young reader’s slow reading speed and limited experience of the world, where “phrases are enormous chunks of sculpture, weightlessly penetrating space”. O’Brien follows this by suggesting that what is more desirable is reduction and encapsulation: “a box with the world in it: that’s what’s wanted.” Yet while it is true that “it’s a victory over time to shrink all the hours that would have spent reading them into these minutes”, he also claims of the author or ‘storyteller’ that “I have cheated him.” It is dubious that somehow ‘cheating’ the author is really the point of reading prose. Brevity certainly does not constitute superiority, and the more reducible a text, the more at risk it is of having its richness and substance lost.
It is then however that O’Brien reconciles this notion with the idea of writing as an equally important and fulfilling component of the literary process, with reading as an equivalent and mutual process of invention. The question “In what space does he exist, if not inside her head, a head that exists nowhere but in his deciphering of her words?” conveys this notion of their being a relationship between writer and reader where the two essentially create each other through the correlating processes of authorship and the imagination of the reader filling the spaces and the forms put in place by the author. It is hopeful, then, that this process does not leave the reader and writer with the same sense of horror experienced by the Lovecraft character mentioned in the quote from The Shadow Out of Time.
From this is the concept expressed in the eponymous section titled “The Browser’s Ecstasy”, in which it is essentially suggested that by being part of the shared concept of literature, all such written works are in some intrinsic fashion related and metafictional: “It’s almost as if the books read each other, the way characters in novels read novels.” Literature, especially fiction, shares these common elements of narrative and causality which unite them into a plausible whole regardless of how unrelated “Inspector French” may be from “a world consisting of nothing but Canada” or “the paranoid century, the reader’s own.” O’Brien compares this in the final section to the perceived obligations of what he terms “true reading”, that to examine a work in its totality is quite a different kind of world-containment than is perceived by viewing the whole continuity of fiction in one great browse of snippets, but surely this is the fulfilment of the ecstasy of the browser: that it permits a choice for specificity and focus, the deeper freedom to “tear open the box of stories looking for what was still hidden in it, the one I haven’t heard.”
Your interpretation of the O'Brien article, Alistair, reminds me very much of Tolstoy (as in the great Russian writer) 's contributions to the philosophy of ethics. Tolstoy argues essentially that the purpose of art is to clearly communicate the feelings one has to another, ostensibly as succinctly as possible. I agree, as you say, that brevity at the expense of quality is not desirable, but surely verbosity at the expense of quality is equally inartistic, especially in literature? Some of the best novels I have read have been some of the shortest - think of that delightful fable 'The Little Prince' by Antoine de-Saint Expury.
ReplyDeleteI have little to no knowledge of Tolstoy, or Antoine de Saint-Exupéry and his writing, but I agree that verbosity can be equally harmful to artistry. In my opinion, literature should be as short or as long as it needs to be to express itself in the best manner possible; it is certainly possible for a text to labour its point excessively - consider Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged, which under novelistic pretensions becomes a tedious and repetitive Objectivist diatribe of over one thousand pages, leaving the reader exhausted and the message rendered smug and self-gratifying in an entirely needless fashion. In the same way I daresay there are novels of needlessly short length, the ideas of which fail to fully develop, although no immediate examples leap to mind. Literature is variable and it certainly does not owe its readers length nor brevity, yet it should make its point in the manner which is 'just right'. This is an unquantifiable and indeterminate amount, but that is the nature of art - it is unscientific and immeasurable, and therein lies its far superior value.
ReplyDeleteI thought your interpretation was very interesting Alistair. I guess I read the article a little differently and felt that O'Brien was evoking an idea of literature as unraveling, and non-rigid- where writing is not contained to the structure that it is printed and edited through. Rather amidst the 'browser's ecstasy,' literature is experienced by the reader incredibly subjectively and contingently, dependent on the situatedness of the reader- which is profoundly valuable.
ReplyDelete