Monday, October 4, 2010

Henry James, What Maisie Knew

So as I strive to head off the deadline for blog posts I have opted to take a rather retroactive, course-wise, examination of Henry James’ What Maisie Knew, and what else can be said of it with the benefit of hindsight. In many ways I feel that much of what we have discussed over the course of the semester has involved comparing the perceptions and responses of readers in the simplest sense to that of critics, the purpose and experience of reading as opposed to that of criticism. I strove, as I try to with the majority of literary works, to read and critique What Maisie Knew simultaneously.
What did the novel present to me as a reader? I must confess that the novel did not grip me. I did not find it to be a page-turner. But the critical side of me argues that that is hardly the point. It may be difficult for me to accept, aesthete as I am, but it is very possible for a pacey narrative and strong emotional involvement to distract from the more serious intellectual concerns of a piece of art. This is Victorian literature, after all, with the novel in a relatively early stage of coalescence, and to make a comparison of my limited reading of such fiction, I daresay that Great Expectations, however unbearably tedious I may have found it during my quickly-defeated effort to read the great work, probably has a good deal more to say than a contemporary work such as my beloved Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.
In that sense I think What Maisie Knew has an immense amount to say. One need only glance at the absurdly evasive and euphemistic dialogue of the inarguably foppish Sir Claude to see James’ harsh examination of an upper crust devoid of responsibility and conscience. To pick an example more or less at random, “Her situation, by what has happened, is completely changed; and it’s no use your trying to prove to me that I needn’t take any account of that.” This is Sir Claude in regards to Mrs Beale. Personally at times I could make nothing of what the more heated conversations between the main characters involved due to this incredibly vague use of language, a language where pronouns are used as often as possible to avoid saying names out loud and where complicated romantic and social liaisons are referenced solely by terms like “situation”. It is a world where children are used in affairs too adult for their involvement, and where the process of growing up involves developing into one of these irresponsible, childish creatures such as the four “parents” of the story, selfish and decadent, engaging endlessly in pointless adolescent-like shenanigans.
Maisie’s departure with Mrs. Wix from her two step-parents at the conclusion of the novel expresses a fitting resolution: that only those who are involved with this upper hierarchy but do not come from it can provide some sort of common sense and hope. That in itself opens up the opportunity for many more readings. What this suggests to me, therefore, that as much as it may strive to be separated and objective, criticism is tied and connected to any other form of reading, and that a critique is ultimately just as subjective as any form of entertainment value. I hope to be able to further develop this concept in my ongoing posts.

6 comments:

  1. I think Sherlock Holmes actually appeared about a decade before Maisie, but I see what you mean. I don't really think a work has to have nothing going on in order to 'tell us' something, but then, I did find Maisie pretty gripping, personally! Maybe I'm just easily entertained :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Indeed, A Study in Scarlet was published in 1887 compared to the 1897 of What Maisie Knew, but of course the Victorian Age lasted a long time. I agree with you that a narrative can have things 'going on' as you put it and also have something to say, and I'm not saying that What Maisie Knew lacks that. I just personally found it somewhat difficult to engage with the text. As my conclusion suggested, I have been discovering a closer connection between intellectual and entertainment value than I previously considered in regards to this kind of literature, and hopefully I can elaborate upon this more effectively in my forthcoming examination of The Secret History.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I didn't find What Maisie Knew to be a page turner either. I found it hard work. The feeling of being wrapped and bound up in subtlety, as well as the superfluity of replacement in Maisie's life, was a bit excruciating. I wanted to get into the insides of the text, not in an Essentialist sense, but just in terms of readerly engagement. Maybe I was also hoping for something consolatory in the text.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The first time I read the novel a few years ago I also found it quite difficult going and not very engaging. I think I often had to re-read sections of the book because I would read fairly quickly, as I do for most novels, but then after a page or two would realise I had no idea what was happening. But when I was reading the novel this semester I realised (helped by class discussions) that the sense of reading being 'excruciating' is actually part of one of the really interesting aspects of the novel. That is, the reader only sees what Maisie sees, and so at times we only get subtle hints of what the adults are really doing. This means that we too experience what it is like to be a little girl living in the world that Maisie is living in, trying to make sense of all the strange people and strange happenings. And while this may not make the novel a page-turner, I certainly enjoyed and appreciated James' writing much more this time.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Em, me too. I found it a frustrating read, but surprisingly, much more enjoyable than 'Portrait of a Lady'. I also wanted to get to the "insides" and maybe by this we mean, well, what Maisie really did know - I felt that whilst I sort of 'got' what she knew, the fact that she was so young meant that the intimacy that can be created by character and reader was never really created. Perhaps a little self-indulgent of me to desire this.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I mean *created between character and reader

    ReplyDelete